SelectBlinds Review: Fit Rules, Remake Policy, and Per-Window Math

SelectBlinds earns its standing on the one thing that matters most in a made-to-size purchase: it publishes the rules before you spend a dollar. You can read the measuring guide, confirm that inside-mount deductions are taken for you at the factory, and find the remake terms in plain English — all without adding anything to a cart. For a product where a mistyped fraction becomes a wrong-size shade you cannot send back, that transparency is the whole ballgame. Graded on fit confidence, SelectBlinds is one of the safer direct-to-consumer blinds sellers to buy from. It has one habit worth calling out, though, and it is the pricing theater.

The fit-confidence check

Three questions decide whether a custom order is a calculated purchase or a coin flip. SelectBlinds passes all three.

Is the measuring guide published? Yes. SelectBlinds keeps public How-to-Measure pages for inside and outside mounts, broken out by product type, plus short video walkthroughs. You do not need an account to read them, which is the bar a spec-honest seller should clear. The guide also states the practical constraint most buyers miss: cellular shades need a minimum flat depth to mount cleanly inside the frame, so a shallow window may push you to an outside mount whether you planned for it or not. Check depth before you fall in love with a fabric.

Are the deductions stated? Yes, and this is the part first-time buyers get wrong everywhere. On an inside mount, SelectBlinds asks for the exact window-opening width and applies the factory deduction for you. Read SelectBlinds' own measuring instructions first and follow them literally: because the configurator deducts behind the scenes, you must not subtract a fraction yourself, or you will double-deduct and hang a shade with light gaps down both sides. For an outside mount the logic flips — you add overlap for light control and privacy, typically a few inches per side, and SelectBlinds builds to the size you enter. Our Measure and Mount Fit Checker shows the typical 1/4-inch to 1/2-inch inside-mount deduction range so you understand what the factory is doing, but the seller's rule always wins — SelectBlinds' guide is the one that governs your order. If you are new to this, walk through how to measure for cellular shades before you touch the configurator.

Is the remake policy real? Yes, and it is a genuine differentiator. Every order includes free FIT Protection: Measuring Guarantee. If you make a measuring mistake, you file a claim and SelectBlinds remakes the covered product to your corrected size and ships it at no additional cost. The limit is one remake per covered product from the original order. That is a real, written safety net — not a vague "satisfaction promise." It is also why a first-timer nervous about the tape measure can order here with less dread than almost anywhere else.

Per-window pricing

SelectBlinds prices cellular shades by the classic ladder: a value cordless line at the bottom, upgraded fabrics in the middle, and a premium double-cell or designer tier on top. The published starting prices below are what the site shows before size and options; the benchmark-size figures are representative estimates so you can sanity-check a quote, not scraped configurator numbers.

Prices quoted at analysis, August 2026. "From" prices are SelectBlinds' published starting prices; 35×48 and 72×48 figures are representative estimates — the configurator's number moves with size, cell type, liner, and lift, so price your exact window on the site. Custom blinds are made-to-size and generally not returnable; confirm the remake policy before ordering.

Here is the honest caveat: SelectBlinds runs near-constant percentage-off promotions, so the crossed-out "regular" price is rarely what anyone pays. That is not a reason to distrust the brand, but it is a reason to ignore the MSRP theater entirely. Judge SelectBlinds by the post-discount per-window number on the sizes you actually need, and compare that against a like-for-like configuration elsewhere. A 40-percent-off banner on an inflated list price can land at the same real dollars as a competitor's plain sticker.

What the price actually buys

The number climbs with four levers, and it helps to know them before you flinch at a quote. Cell type is the big one: a double-cell shade traps more air and insulates better than a single cell, and it costs more. Fabric opacity — sheer, light-filtering, room-darkening, blackout — steps up in price as it blocks more light. Lift matters most: cordless is the standard, top-down/bottom-up adds a modest premium, and motorization is a large jump that can double a window. Size is continuous, not banded, so a 72-inch-wide shade is not simply "large" pricing — it is priced to its exact square footage. If a quote looks high, the fastest lever to check is whether you selected blackout or a motor you do not actually need.

Policies: remakes, samples, and warranty

Remakes and returns. Because everything is cut to your size, SelectBlinds cannot offer a refund or exchange unless a product is defective — the industry norm, and worth stating plainly: custom blinds are made-to-size and generally not returnable, so confirm the remake policy before you order. What softens that here is a 90-day satisfaction remake: within the first 90 days, if you dislike the color or want a different lift or mount, SelectBlinds will remake the same product in the same size at the same discounted price you paid, plus an additional 10 percent off. It is a remake, not a refund, but it is more generous than most.

Samples. Free sample swatches ship within about two business days. Order them. On cellular fabrics especially, "light-filtering" covers a wide range of opacity, and a swatch against your own window at your own light is the cheapest insurance you will buy in this whole process. Our free-sample strategy guide covers how to compare them without stalling for weeks.

Warranty. The base is a 3-year limited warranty at no cost, with 5-year and unlimited coverage available at checkout for an added fee. That base term is shorter than the limited-lifetime coverage you get on Bali and Levolor product bought through a retailer, which is worth weighing if longevity is your priority. Read the fine print on the paid upgrade before you buy it — for a cordless cellular shade in a low-traffic room, the base three years is usually enough.

One factual note for households with young children: SelectBlinds' cellular shades are cordless by default, which aligns with CPSC guidance and the industry's ANSI/WCMA standard that has moved stock window coverings to cordless operation. Cordless is the recommended choice around kids and pets — stated as a fact, not a scare.

The honest cons

Three things keep SelectBlinds from a clean sweep. First, the perpetual-sale pricing means you never quite know if you got the "real" price or just a well-timed banner — you have to do the per-window math yourself. Second, FIT Protection is one remake per product; a second measuring mistake on the same window is on you. Third, the base warranty is three years, and matching Bali or Levolor's longevity means paying to extend it. None of these is a dealbreaker, but all three reward a buyer who reads before clicking.

Who it's for, and who should pass

Buy SelectBlinds if you are a first-time custom buyer who wants a written measuring safety net, you like ordering swatches before you commit, and you want a broad catalog spanning cellular, roller, roman, and faux-wood without hopping between sites. The FIT Protection guarantee alone makes it a sensible default for anyone nervous about the tape measure.

Look elsewhere if you need a true money-back return (no custom seller offers that, so this is a category limitation, not a SelectBlinds flaw), if you want limited-lifetime warranty coverage baked in at no cost, or if perpetual-sale pricing wears you down and you would rather shop a flat, honest sticker.

Verdict

SelectBlinds grades well on the two things this site cares about most: fit confidence and spec honesty. The measuring guides are public, the inside-mount deduction is handled for you, and the FIT Protection remake is a real, written guarantee rather than marketing gauze. The catch is the pricing theater — treat the "regular" price as noise and evaluate the discounted per-window number on your exact sizes. Do that, order swatches, follow SelectBlinds' own measuring guide to the letter, and this is a low-anxiety way to buy custom shades. For the closest head-to-head, see SelectBlinds vs Blinds.com; if you are still deciding on shade type, start with cellular vs roller shades.